Hydrogen car

Hydrogen cars convert gas into electricity via a fuel cell. The electricity is also used to form hydrogen gas. This is the biggest weakness of a hydrogen car compared to a battery-powered car. The process of transporting electricity via hydrogen gas results in poorer utilization of the energy than storing the current in a battery.

Hydrogen car – at least one good reason

Hyundai Tucson IX35 FCEV.

Although "everyone" buys electric cars and "no one" buys hydrogen cars, I have kept the faith that hydrogen cars still have the right of life. Today, faith has become stronger.

 

A good reason

From 6 May, the electric cars were thrown out of the public transport zone from the E18 west of Oslo. Today's happy news in Asker og Bærum Budstikke and Avisa Oslo is about Margrethe Wam Solvang who is a hydrogen car owner and can speed into the public transport lane perfectly legally. "- I smile and wave to the police who carry out checks", she says – and the police smile and wave back. The ban on electric cars in public transport does not apply to hydrogen cars. They do not need to bring any passengers with them, nor do they have to pay tolls or parking fees in Oslo. Today, as "all" new cars are electric cars, it is probably only a matter of time before electric cars are banished from public transport lanes elsewhere as well. Then you can ask yourself:

 

hydrogen car
Toyota Mirai 2 (Photo: MikeMareen/depositphotos.com)
hydrogen car
Hyundai Nexo Fuel Cell

Is the time to rethink hydrogen cars?

There are not terribly many hydrogen cars to choose from - neither in Norway nor elsewhere in the world. Of new cars there are Toyota Mirai or Hyundai Nexo. Toyota has a range of 650 km and Hyundai has 666 km. Prices for the Toyota Mirai start at NOK 788, while the Hyundai Nexo no longer appears on Norwegian price lists, but according to German price lists it would cost approximately NOK 400 more than the Mirai. The point is that if you need a hydrogen car to drive in the public transport zone - and thus make your everyday life better, you might as well buy a used hydrogen car. A 100-year-old Toyota Mirai Fuel Cell will do just fine for many years to come.

Fuel cell in brief

I like the designation fuel cell (fuel cell) well. It is the one that converts the hydrogen gas into electricity - which makes the car move. Electricity is also used to form hydrogen gas. This is the biggest weakness of a hydrogen car compared to a battery-powered car. The process of transporting electricity via hydrogen gas results in poorer utilization of the energy than storing the current in a battery.

 

Toyota Mirai 2 close-up (Photo: Wirestock/depositphotos.com)

 
Hyundai Nexo Fuel Cell hydrogen tank (Photo: autodatanet/depositphotos.com)

 
Hyundai Nexo interior

Batteries for trouble

The problems with today's electric cars are swept under the rug. It is not allright that a regular family car with a long range should constantly transport a battery weighing 700+ kg. They just build bigger and heavier cars without focusing on the problems it creates - during production, during their lifetime and during scrapping. Furthermore, it is difficult to imagine how cities of millions full of street-parked cars will function with electric cars. Electrifying today's heavy traffic with batteries is even more unthinkable. At the border crossing in La Jonquera between France and Spain, for example, 10 wagon trains pass every 000 hours. The roads on the continent are filled with commercial traffic.

The big bang

I was standing up on Bjerke and thinking - or charging - in June 2019 when it slammed. A sharp bang that I felt from the ground into my body. The hydrogen station for Uno-X at Kjørbo in Sandvika outside Oslo had blown up. Today there is only one functioning hydrogen station in Norway. It is located in Høvik. Hynion AS which runs the station, has plans to open a station in Porsgrunn as well. The lack of hydrogen stations is probably determined by the market. Uno-X pulled out after the bang. Today's company has plans to build more stations, but is dependent on the market picking up. It will require incentives from the authorities, such as being able to continue driving in public transport lanes. A very good reason for many.

 

hydrogen car
Uno-X hydrogen station before it went live
hydrogen car
Hynion Høvik (Source: Google Maps)

Price

according to Hydrogenbil.net 1 kg of hydrogen costs NOK 195. It is enough for about 10 miles when driving calmly. The high price is due to the fact that it is expensive to produce hydrogen. Furthermore, there are no alternatives to Norway's only functioning hydrogen station.
 


A good, affordable hydrogen car is, for example, the 2016 Toyota Mirai or the Hyundai Tucson IX35 – both with prices starting at around NOK 200.


 

hydrogen car
Toyota Mirai in Ullevål Hageby.

2016 Toyota Mirai Fuel Cell

Car type: Sedan 4 doors
Number of seats: 4
Front wheel drive
Horse power: 154 hp
Torque: 335 Nm
Top speed: 175 km/h
0-100: 9,6 seconds
Range: 550 km
Battery capacity: 1,6 kWh
Length, width, height in cm: 489, 181, 154
Wheelbase in cm: 278
Luggage compartment: 361 litres
Trailer weight: Not possible
Own weight: 1850 kg
Total weight: 2180 kg

fuel cell
Follow that Mirai!

 

2016 Hyundai Tucson IX35 FCEV

2016 Hyundai Tucson IX35 FCEV

Car type: Crossover combi 5 doors
Number of seats 5
Front wheel drive
Horse power: 136 hp
Torque: –
Top speed: 160 km/h
0-100:-
Range: 594 km
Battery capacity: 1,0 kWh
Length, width, height in cm: 441, 182, 165
Wheelbase in cm: 264
Luggage compartment: 488 litres
Trailer weight: Not possible
Own weight: 1846 kg
Total weight: 2250 kg

Hyundai ix35 FCEV interior

 

See

Toyota Mirai – designed for hybrid

Norwegian Hydrogen Car Association
Hynion AS
Norway's only hydrogen station with record attendance

Toyota Mirai – designed for hydrogen

toyota mirai
The hydrogen car Toyota Mirai.

The Toyota Mirai appears to be a bit of an enigma. It is not particularly beautiful, not particularly cheap, - and where did the hydrogen stations in Oslo become? Still, there's something about the Mirai that appeals to me.

 

Camry at the bottom

Mirai shares chassis, electric motor and hybrid components with Camry hybrid XV50 (2012-2015). The wheelbase is the same as in the Camry, but to accommodate the fuel cells, hydrogen tanks and battery pack, the front and rear overhangs have been increased. The designers of Toyota's first series-produced hydrogen car were not given free rein. Maybe they could have built hydrogen power into the existing Camry, but how wise is it to introduce new cutting-edge technology into an old winner? Then it was safer to create a new design and give the hydrogen project more attention.

Why only four seats?

toyota mirai
Good headroom in the back seat.
Why are there only four seats in the Mirai? What is hidden under the large center console between the rear seats? After studying photos and film clips from various phases of the production, I can't see any vital parts there. The answer lies in the heritage of the Camry. The Mirai has also inherited the Camry's overall weight. Equipped for hydrogen operation, the car simply cannot withstand the weight of five adults.
 
The leather-covered rear seats provide first-class comfort. I wouldn't mind being driven home in a Mirai Taxi, but unfortunately lack of space - and weight restrictions - become an obstacle to success in the taxi industry. A shame, because comfort is actually one of the Mirai's strongest cards. On 17-inch studless Nokian winter tires, the car literally runs silently within the city speed limits. The Camry would hardly have been among America's top three car models over a number of years if the chassis did not deliver a comfortable "ride". Mirai enjoys it.

What signals does Mirai send?

I mentioned that there is something about the Mirai that appeals to me. The front seems somewhat vulgar with its large air intakes and vertical lines. I think they harmonize poorly with the aerodynamic, flattering lines that otherwise appear in the side profile. Corresponding vertical lines are found at the transition between the rear screen and the back piece. The disharmony in the lines, if you can call it that the, also helps to give the car a tough and functional feel. One can certainly defend the vulgar air intakes by saying that fuel cells need a lot of oxygen and apparently a lot of cooling, too.
 
So what appeals to me? I like cars that stand out, that have character and that are not too common. You'd think the Mirai looks like it does, because it runs on hydrogen. Perhaps that was the designers' intention? Other hydrogen-powered cars, such as the Hyundai ix35, look like a normal ix35. The new Hyundai Nexo Fuel Cell also looks pretty normal. The Mirai, on the other hand, stands out.
 
Mirai's CW value is 0,29. It's like a normal, good family car. The Toyota Prius and Hyundai Ioniq have, by comparison, 0,24.

 

toyota mirai
Toyota Mirai in Ullevål Hageby.

Wrong technology?

Today, there is a lot of focus on what is the "right" technology. If you choose the wrong technology, you may have problems selling your car in the future. The number of hydrogen stations has unfortunately decreased. Today, I believe that the Oslo area's only hydrogen station is at Kjørbo in Sandvika. With a stated range of 550 km, you shouldn't drive more than 400-450 km between each fill-up. Thus, hydrogen cars are not suitable for all types of driving. Hydrogen is undoubtedly the "wrong technology", at least today. You should therefore not purchase hydrogen car, but rather lease or rent. The car collective previously had the Mirai in its fleet, but has had to give it up due to problems finding hydrogen stations.

No big seller

Over the past few months, it may look like the new Tesla 3 is about to take the US by storm, especially in California, of course. In January (2019), 6 Tesla 500s were sold in the USA. At the same time, 3 Toyota Mirai and 77 Hyundai Nexo were sold. There will be approximately 35 hydrogen stations in California. In the rest of the United States, there are almost none. In Norway, registration number HY31 has recently been issued. A quick search shows that many number series are unused, such is the number of hydrogen cars on the road today not 340. I would assume that the real number is half. 134 hydrogen cars were registered in 2016 and 2017.
 
Hydrogen is ideal for company vehicles that are more or less in constant operation - or in constant readiness. Sales are unlikely to increase until you start to see a network of hydrogen stations. Still tax relief, zero emissions and the possibility to thought instead of charging, are good arguments for hydrogen.
 


Hydrogen cars are hardly just a fad. Visions of getting the entire car fleet to zero emissions cannot be realized with a unilateral investment in electric cars, neither in Norway nor in the rest of the world. Therefore, I hope Toyota continues its investment in hydrogen.


 

toyota mirai
Water vapor and clean water flow from the drain hole under the car. The water is supposedly drinkable.

 

toyota mirai
Class in the back seat.

Drive and performance

Horsepower: 154
Torque: 335 from 0 revs
Top speed: 175 km/6
0-100: 9,6 seconds

Weights and Measures

Length, width, height in cm: 489, 181, 154
Wheelbase in cm: 278
Track width front, rear in cm: 154, 155
Luggage compartment: 361 litres
Trailer weight: Not possible
Own weight: 1850 kg
Total weight: 2180 kg

Price

559.000 NOK

Technique

toyota miraiWhen the fuel cells are supplied with hydrogen and oxygen, a reaction takes place that produces electricity – and clean water. The electricity is distributed to the electric motor and to the battery pack. It is the size of the battery packs in today's hybrid cars and is supplied with electricity, including by recovering braking power.

In the picture, the fuel cells are located directly under the seat cushions. There are two hydrogen tanks, one for filling and one for expansion. One tank is located directly under the seat cushions in the rear seat, the other (not visible in the picture) is located between the back of the rear seat and the luggage compartment, directly behind the rear axle. Above, up to the rear seat back is the battery pack.

Sources

Toyota.no
Owner of pictured cars: Toyota Business Plus, Økern
Test drives and viewings were on occasion The car collective and Oslo City Council's inauguration of reserved parking spaces for car sharing at Damplassen, Ullevål Hageby.

Toyota Mirai pictures

Click on the images to see them in a larger format.

toyota mirai
On the road.
toyota mirai
Follow that Mirai!
toyota mirai
The Hydrogen concept shown on the dashboard.
toyota mirai
The luggage compartment holds 361 litres, - the same size as in the 5-door Auris hybrid.
toyota mirai
Toyota Mirai and I-Pace could be test driven by the residents of Ullevål Hageby on the occasion of the inauguration of parking spaces at Damplassen.

See

toyota mirai
Oslo opens its own parking spaces for car sharing
Will hydrogen be the petrol stations' salvation?