i3 winter

When I drove the car in summer driving, I was worried that the powerful engine brake could lock the rear wheels so that the rear end flipped out in winter driving. It is not tempting to lose traction in the turn without being able to disengage the rear wheels. What happens, however, is that the anti-skid system (DSC) and the traction control (DCT) take over control completely. These systems are very dominant. In short, you don't lose control, just the joy of driving actively on winter roads.

How many kWh does the Tesla 3 lose in the blast cold?

preheating tesla 3
Battery loss in the cold

Electric car owners in cold regions certainly have good access to electricity where they park. But what happens if you are visiting and have to leave the electric car overnight in the freezing cold without access to electricity?

 

Looking for the cold

It was reported -16 degrees, but already after Lillehammer I saw that the degrees crept down to -18. It looked promising for a cold test. In Gudbrandsdalen, temperatures can vary with local conditions. I was on my way to check the holiday home before the winter holidays. Thawing water pipes, turning on the heat, shoveling, putting up firewood, chasing away mice, as well as other necessary caretaker tasks. It takes time to fire up a house with an inside temperature of 4 degrees. The cold did not disappoint. During the evening and night, the outside temperature dropped to -24,9 degrees.

The cold steals kilowatt-hours

I parked the Tesla with 80% on the batteries after charging on Øyer. The remaining battery capacity decreased in line with the falling outside temperature, but stabilized at 73% when the thermometer stopped at -24 degrees. During the night, 7% of the batteries had evaporated in the cold - of Tesla's 75 kwh, this amounts to 5,25 kwh.

preheating the batteries
Cold degrees

Lightning-fast heating of the compartment

Ready to leave, I started heating the cabin by preheating the batteries at the same time as scraping the windows. Scraping wasn't really necessary. The car warmed up long before I expected - much faster than in modern petrol cars. After I had turned off the water in the laundry cellar, loaded the luggage into the car and locked the house, the car was wonderfully warm and ice-free. Almost 15 minutes had passed.

Just driving?

The heating had taken another 2% of the batteries. They were now down to 71%. In total, the night had cost 9% of the battery capacity (6,75 kwh). But I was a little too quick on my feet to get off. The app that heats up the car shows a battery symbol with an ice rose when it preheats the batteries. It switches off when the temperature in the batteries is 19 degrees. I preheated for 15 minutes. Ideally, I should have continued preheating until the battery symbol went out. Preheating the batteries is not only for comfort, but to make the best use of the remaining battery capacity. If the batteries are too cold, they will not accept charging from regenerative energy. It therefore pays to preheat the batteries even if the car is not plugged in. I could have preheated for maybe 30-60 minutes. All monners leave. 15-20 minutes drains maybe 2 percent of the batteries, but makes the batteries give more range when you start driving.

Preheating the batteries

The pre-heating in the Tesla 3 uses the electric motors to produce the heat. The heating of the batteries is water-based – coolant that passes through all the cells. The pre-heating does not drain more power from the batteries than quiet driving, so you can start the pre-heating in good time. When you come from petrol and diesel cars, you are set on getting off as soon as the routes are ice-free. But preheating electric cars does not generate any toxic gases or noise. You can optionally start pre-heating without the air conditioning - or low temperature in the passenger compartment and gradually turn up the heat to save the batteries.

preheating tesla
Tesla Supercharger on Øyer. -16 and wind made it colder than it looks.

Slow charging in the cold

Although the batteries had not reached ideal temperature, they worked fine from the first kilometer. Consumption was the same as the day before. After 1 mile of driving, I set my destination to a charging station to buy coffee and sausage - and test charging. Tesla preheats the batteries before arrival, which in my case was calculated for 10 minutes. The batteries thus received additional preheating to cope with the cold. But the batteries were probably not quite ready to receive electricity. It took a few minutes before charging started, and then with low power. Although I was the only customer at Tesla's Supercharger facility, the maximum charging power did not reach more than 27 Kw during my little lunch break. The day before, the batteries received 87 Kw. But I didn't really need much power, so when the break was over, I moved on.

No big increase in consumption

The experts warn against higher electricity consumption in the cold - up to 41% higher than in summer. My winter consumption on the section Oslo - Øyer this trip was 25% higher than the lowest record measurement from September last year - and about the same level as other measurements made in warmer temperatures under alternating driving and driving conditions. Nor did the trip up offer any surprises in terms of range. I don't know if it is of great importance, but I drive with a thick sweater and an indoor temperature between 19-20 degrees. It is possible T-shirt and 25 degrees could have given other experiences.

 

Don't forget to preheat the batteries in the cold!

 

thaw thirteen
Water vapor looks dramatic in the cold. From here The Tine plant at Tretten.

Tesla Owners Club Norway: Battery heating

See

Tesla Model 3 Long Range
terjes cars
Life with Tesla 3
Temperature control of electric car batteries
Active battery cooling?

 

BMW i3 as a winter car

winter car
Winter driving is no problem for the i3.

When I last wrote about the i3, I was worried about how the powerful engine brake would work as a winter car in winter conditions.

 

If you drive a BMW i3, you can get through traffic without touching the brake pedal. If you release the gas pedal suddenly, you get a powerful engine brake that slows the car completely. When I drove the car in the summer, I was worried that the powerful engine brake could lock the rear wheels so that the rear end would spin out.
 
The i3 is not a car I like to test the limits with on winter roads. It is not tempting to lose traction in the turn without being able to disengage the rear wheels. What happens, however, is that the anti-skid system (DSC) and the traction control (DCT) take over control completely. These systems are very dominant. In short, you don't lose control, just the joy of driving actively on winter roads.
 
I take the car out to an icy parking lot in Sørkedalen to see if I can get the rear end to kick out when the engine brakes. With a thin layer of snow over bare ice, I maintained 40 km/h down a gentle slope and let off the gas suddenly without any drama. The engine brake didn't seem to engage, either. On the way back up, the traction control held me back by throttling the engine long before the wheels started spinning. It was only as far as I came up. I think the traction control could be a little less dominant.
 
I think this sums up the i3's winter characteristics quite well. Rear-wheel drive and automatic engine braking work safely because the electronics take over the steering. It also takes over the desire to challenge the car's limits.
 
Another reason why I don't want to challenge the car on winter driving is the i3's steering servo. No matter what happens, the servo provides constant resistance - or inertia. I don't think too much about it during normal road driving, but the sluggishness of the steering will certainly be experienced as unpleasant if you suddenly need to countersteer due to the rear end kicking out.

Likes and dislikes

The last time I wrote about the i3, I gave out grades on the various test categories such as look-and-feel, driving pleasure, comfort, space, etc. I still stand by these grades today, but would like to supplement with additional "likes" and "dislikes" - in other words, purely subjective considerations on my part.

winter car
Nice atmosphere behind the wheel.

Look-and-feel

There have been many i3s on the road. The slightly odd design has clearly not scared off the buyers. One of BMW's chief designers has previously told me how much the designers worked to give BMW's first electric car an environmental touch. Now, in retrospect, I think they should have given the car a more aggressive look. I notice that some drivers do everything to get in front of the i3 in traffic, as if it were a moped.
 
The music system, the screens on the dashboard, the setting wheel between the seats and the frameless doors contribute to creating a pleasant atmosphere in the car. "My" car only has a 6,5 inch screen (606 business navigation) while I think most people choose the large 10,2 inch screen (609 Professional navigation). The wider the screen, the better the atmosphere. If you are considering buying an i3, you should also bring the i3's with you ConnectedDrive and the ability to control charging and heating via a mobile app.
 
I don't like the furry plastic on the dashboard and doors. I have read that this material is made from recycled plastic bottles. BMW could have made it darker and more matte. Today, it gives an unfortunate glare in the sunlight, and does not contribute to creating a better atmosphere either.

 winter car
I like the center screen. This is the small screen (6,5″). You also get a wide screen (10,2″).

Driving pleasure

Braking and accelerating with the same pedal is made for traffic jams. It is also well suited for driving in central Oslo. I don't like it quite as much when I drive on country roads. I prefer to have full control over when the brake lights come on. I know they come on automatically when the engine brake is activated, but never know exactly when. Occasionally, an early brake light can prevent dangerous situations on the road. Driving with one pedal caused no problems on winter roads.
 
I'm also not completely sloppy with the steering. The steering servo provides constant resistance throughout. Especially around the center position, it feels different to other vehicles. It also feels different when maneuvering the car in a car park and when parking.

winter car
This is how a user interface on board should be.

Comfort

I always turn down the temperature a bit in electric cars, because I imagine that I get a longer range by choosing 18 degrees instead of 20, without having any tests to back it up. I also think there is a lot to be saved by having the car parked in a heated garage instead of outdoors. My impression is that the air conditioning also works well in winter, without significantly reducing the range. I think the instrument panel indicates the range quite accurately even in winter, without having tested the limit for when the batteries are actually empty. I haven't had the need to start outdoors in minus 30 degrees, either.
 
Today the range meter showed that I had 117 kilometers available in the morning and 40 kilometers in the evening. By then I had driven 79 actual kilometres, while the range meter showed 77. I think that's good.
 
In my first post about the i3, I wrote that the car took bumps in the road very well, probably because of the big wheels. This is correct, but larger bumps, such as speed bumps, it doesn't take as well as I would expect. I felt that the Citroen C1 took the speed bumps far more comfortably than the i3, despite having a shorter wheelbase.

Roadside.
Roadside.

Place

This is a 2+2 seater. Two adults in the front, and two children in the back. Front and rear trunks should hold for most people. I just had room for a full garbage bag and two carrier bags with empty bottles in the rear trunk. There is plenty of room up to the windshield. When I also sit quite high, I almost get the feeling of a minibus.


A mild and good February creates no problems for an i3.


Frameless doors - I like!
Frameless doors - I like!
winter car
Best range with the electric car in the garage.

 

 

See

BMW i3 120Ah
Blue BMW kidneys for the i3
Blue BMW kidneys for the i3